Случаи проведения любых форм эвтана

Случаи проведения любых форм эвтаназии в Украине считаются противоправными и квалифицируются как убийство, — объясняет адвокат Екатерина Тарасова, — поэтому и рассматриваются в суде по соответствующим статьям Уголовного кодекса. Ведь одним из важнейших прав, обеспечивающих само физическое существование человека как биологического существа, согласно ст. 27 Конституции, является право на жизнь. А ст. 3 Основного Закона закрепляет положение, по которому человек, его неприкосновенность и безопасность признаются в Украине высшей социальной ценностью. Право на жизнь гарантирует неприкосновенность физического существования человека. А на удовлетворение просьбы о прекращении его жизни наложен запрет в Гражданском кодексе Украины и ряде статей медицинского законодательства. Однако мнение украинского общества по этому вопросу не так категорично, как действующее законодательство. Из результатов опроса, проведенного в октябре 2011 г. институтом Горшенина среди 1 тыс. респондентов в различных регионах Украины, удалось установить, что против эвтаназии выступают лишь 37,1% опрошенных. А поддерживают ее, в той или иной форме или ситуации, около 62%. Для сравнения, в 2007 г. количество людей, которые были категорически против добровольной смерти для неизлечимо больных, составляла 57%. Как видим, с каждым годом все больше людей начинает поддерживать легализацию эвтаназии. Но до этого в ближайшее время, скорее всего, дело не дойдет. Ведь в Украине большое влияние на общественное мнение оказывает церковь, главный постулат которой — никто и ничто не может дать разрешение на убийство невинного человеческого существа. Согласно христианскому учению, страдания, особенно во время последнего момента жизни, имеют особое место в спасительно Божьем плане. Они являются свидетельством участия в Христовых страданиях и в Его спасительной жертве. При этом церковь не запрещает умеренное употребление обезболивающих средств, облегчающих боль, но не убивающих неизлечимо больного человека. Считается, что таким образом христиане добровольно принимают хотя бы часть страданий в сопоставлении со страдающим и распятым Христом. Существуют и другие причины, по которым в Украине невозможно узаконить эвтаназию. Среди них — увеличение риска давления на инвалидов, престарелых и неизлечимо больных людей со стороны родственников, желающих прибрать к рукам их имущество или наследство. — В наших условиях жизни сложно будет установить добровольность принятия решения о смерти. И даже в том случае, когда согласие пациента — очевидно, всегда существует вероятность того, что он может пересмотреть свое решение. Но начатая процедура лишения жизни уже вызовет необратимые изменения в его организме, — утверждает адвокат, кандидат юридических наук Виктория Тисногуз. — К тому же, процедура эвтаназии может облегчить совершение преступлений путем применения физического или психологического давления на пациента, подкупа медицинского персонала, злоупотребления должностным положением, мошенничества и т.п. Могут возникнуть проблемы с правильностью постановки диагноза и прогнозом дальнейшего развития заболевания, получением согласия пациента, находящегося в бессознательном состоянии, установлением и доказыванием добровольного ухода из жизни, медико-этическими моментами и даже торговлей человеческими органами. В связи с осознанием масштаба возникших в случае легализации эвтаназии проблем, в свое время в Верховной Раде был отклонен соответствующий проект закона. Новых законодательных инициатив по этому вопросу пока не поступало.

Результаты (английский) 1:

Cases of any form of euthanasia in Ukraine are considered illegal and classified as murder, "explains Attorney Yekaterina Tarasova, is therefore dealt with in court under the relevant articles of the criminal code. After all, one of the most important rights ensuring the very physical existence of human as a biological substance, according to art. 27 of the Constitution, is the right to life. And art. 3 of the Basic Law enshrines the provision according to which a man of his integrity and security are recognised in Ukraine as the highest social value. Right to life guarantees the inviolability of the physical existence of man. And the satisfaction of a request to terminate his life bans in the Civil Code of Ukraine and a number of articles of the health legislation. However, the opinion of the Ukrainian society on this issue is not as categorical as legislation. The results of the survey conducted in October 2011 Institute Gorshenina among 1 thous. respondents in various regions of Ukraine, was able to establish that against euthanasia advocate only 37.1% of respondents. And support it in one form or another or situation, about 62%. For comparison, in 2007, the number of people who have been adamantly opposed to voluntary death for the terminally ill, was 57%. As you can see, every year more and more people start to support the legalization of euthanasia. But before that, soon, most likely the case will not come. In fact, in Ukraine a great influence on public opinion is having a main tenet of the Church which is a nobody and nothing can give permission to kill an innocent human being. According to Christian teachings, suffering, especially during the last moments of life, have a special place in God's saving plan. They are evidence of participation in Christ's suffering and His redeeming sacrifice. While the Church does not prohibit the moderate consumption of anesthetics to ease the pain, but not killing a terminally ill person. It is believed that in this way the Christians voluntarily accept at least part of the suffering compared with suffering and crucified Christ. There are other reasons why Ukraine cannot legitimize euthanasia. Among them are an increase in the risk of pressure on persons with disabilities, the elderly and terminally ill people from relatives willing to lay their hands on their property or inheritance. — In our living conditions, it would be difficult to establish the voluntariness of the decision about death. And even when a patient's consent is clear, there is always the possibility that he might reconsider his decision. But the procedure for deprivation of life started already will cause irreversible changes in his body, argues counsel, PhD, Victoria Tisnoguz. — In addition, the procedure can facilitate euthanasia crimes through the use of physical or mental pressure on the patient, bribery of medical personnel, abuse of Office, fraud, etc. may cause problems with correct diagnosis and prognosis of further development of the disease, obtaining the patient's consent, unconscious, establishing and proving a voluntary withdrawal from life, medico-ethical moments and even trafficking in human organs. In connection with the realization of scale arising in case of legalization of euthanasia issues in his time in Parliament was rejected by the draft law. New legislative initiatives on the issue.

Результаты (английский) 2:

The cases of all forms of euthanasia in Ukraine are considered illegal and are qualified as murder, - explains the lawyer Ekaterina Tarasova - and therefore considered in the court under the relevant articles of the Criminal Code. After all, one of the most important rights that ensure the very physical existence of man as a biological being, according to Art. 27 of the Constitution is the right to life. And Art. 3 of the Basic Law enshrines the provision that a person of his integrity and security are recognized in Ukraine as the highest social value. The right to life is guaranteed the inviolability of the physical existence of man. And to meet the request for termination of his lifetime ban in the Civil Code of Ukraine and a number of articles of health legislation. However, the opinion of the Ukrainian society on the issue is not so categorical as the current legislation. From the results of a survey conducted in October 2011 by the Gorshenin Institute among one thousand. Respondents in various regions of Ukraine, it was found that anti-euthanasia advocate only 37.1% of respondents. A support it in some form or situation, about 62%. For comparison, in 2007 the number of people who were strongly against voluntary death for the terminally ill, was 57%. As you can see, every year more and more people are starting to support the legalization of euthanasia. But before that, in the near future, most likely, it will not come. Indeed, in Ukraine, a major influence on public opinion has a church, a central tenet of that - nothing and no one can authorize the killing of an innocent human being. According to Christian teaching, suffering, especially during the last moment of life, have a special place in God's plan of salvation. They are evidence of participation in the sufferings of Christ and his saving sacrifice. Thus the Church does not prohibit the moderate use of analgesics, relieves pain, but do not kill the terminally ill person. It is believed that in this way the Christians voluntarily accept at least some of the suffering in comparison with the suffering and crucifixion of Christ. There are other reasons that in Ukraine is impossible to legalize euthanasia. Among them - the increase in the risk of pressure on the disabled, the elderly and terminally ill people with relatives who want to seize their property or inheritance. - In our conditions, life would be difficult to establish a voluntary decision about death. And even in the case where the patient's consent - obviously, there is always a likelihood that it may reconsider its decision. But the procedure started taking life already cause irreversible changes in his body - says the lawyer, PhD Victoria Tisnoguz. - In addition, the procedure for euthanasia may facilitate the commission of crimes through the use of physical or psychological pressure on the patient, the medical staff of bribery, abuse of official position, fraud, etc. There may be problems with the accuracy of the diagnosis and prognosis of further development of the disease, obtaining the consent of the patient is unconscious, establishing and proving a voluntary withdrawal from life, medical and ethical issues, and even trafficking in human organs. In connection with the realization of the scale of the problems in the case of the legalization of euthanasia problems in his time in Parliament was rejected by the relevant draft law. New legislative initiatives on this issue have not yet been reported.

Результаты (английский) 3:

cases of any form of euthanasia in ukraine are illegal and constitute murder, explains the attorney catherine tarasova.therefore, before the court on the relevant articles of the criminal code. one of the important rights for the physical existence of man as a biological being, according to art.27 of the constitution, is the right to life. and art. 3 of the basic law establishes the position in which the man, his privacy and security are recognized in ukraine high social value.the right to life, guarantees the inviolability of the person.at the request of the end of his life was prohibited in the civil code of ukraine and a number of articles of health law. however, the opinion of the society on this issue not so black and white.as the current legislation. from the results of the survey conducted in october 2011. institute of горшенина among 1 000. respondents in the various regions of ukraine, have been identified.against euthanasia are only 37.1%. and supporting it in one form or another, or the situation, about 62%. for comparison, in 2007. the number of peoplewhich were totally against the voluntary death for the terminally ill, was 57%. as we can see, every year more and more people are beginning to support the legalization of euthanasia. but before that, in the near future.most likely, it won't come. in ukraine, a great impact on public opinion has a church, the premise that no one and nothing can give permission for the murder of an innocent human being.according to the christian teachings, suffering, especially during the last moment of life, have a special place in the спасительно god's plan.they are proof of participation in the suffering of christ and in his rescue of the victim. the church does not prohibit the moderate use of painkillers, ease the painbut killing a terminally ill person. thus, it is believed that christians will take at least some of the suffering in comparison with the suffering and the crucified christ. there are other reasonswhich in ukraine is to legalize euthanasia. among them, increase the risk of pressure on the disabled, the elderly and terminally ill people by relatives.want to get your hands on their property or inheritance. in our conditions, it would be difficult to establish a voluntary decision of the death. and even when a patient's consent - clearthere is always the possibility that he might reconsider its decision. but a forfeiture of life will cause irreversible changes in his system, argues thatcandidate of legal sciences, victoria тисногуз. besides, the procedure of euthanasia can relieve the crimes through the use of physical or psychological pressure to the patient.the medical personnel bribery, abuse of office, fraud and so on. problems may arise with the propriety of the diagnosis and prognosis of the further development of the disease.the consent of the patient unconscious, setting and prove the voluntary withdrawal from life, medical and ethical issues and even trafficking in human organs.in connection with the sense of scale in the case of the legalization of euthanasia problems encountered in my time in the verkhovna rada was rejected a draft law.new legislative initiatives on this issue have been reported yet.