Было достигнуто компромиссное решен

Было достигнуто компромиссное решение: «всячески затягивать подписание мира» (Ленин), «в случае немецкого ультиматума объявить войну прекращенной, но мира не подписывать» (Троцкий). «Мы выходим из войны, но вынуждены отказаться от подписания мирного договора». Германские войска перешли в наступление в направлении Петрограда, Москвы и Киева, сметая на своем пути слабо организованные красноармейские отряды. Была принята ленинская резолюция о заключении мира. Советское правительство получило новый германский ультиматум. Помимо утраты оккупированных территорий, Россия должна была отказаться от Эстонии и Латвии, вывести армию из Финляндии и Украины, заключить с Центральной Радой сепаратный мир, отдать Турции некоторые районы Закавказья, предоставить Германии право беспошлинного вывоза сырья. Позднее ультиматум был дополнен требованиями демобилизации российской армии и флота, уплаты контрибуции в 6 млрд. марок. Всего от России отторгались земли общей площадью в 780 тыс. кв. км с населением 56 млн. человек (треть населения бывшей Российской империи, включая 40% промышленных рабочих). Там находилась почти треть железнодорожной сети страны, выплавлялось более 70% чугуна и стали, добывалось 89% угля. Германский ультиматум был принят, и 3 марта 1918 .г. Так, ценой беспрецедентных в мировой истории уступок, уязвлявших патриотические чувства миллионов российских граждан, большевики сохранили власть над Россией и получили, правда, на короткое время, мирную передышку.

Результаты (английский) 1:

A compromise was reached: "in every way possible to delay the signing of the peace" (Lenin), in the case of a German ultimatum to declare war terminated, but peace did not sign "(Leon Trotsky). "We are coming out of the war, but were forced to abandon the signing of a peace treaty. The Germans launched an offensive in the direction of Petrograd, Moscow and Kiev, sweeping away on his way to storm loosely organized groups. Lenin was adopted a resolution on the conclusion of peace. The Soviet Government received a new German ultimatum. In addition to the loss of the occupied territories, Russia had to withdraw from Estonia and Latvia, to withdraw the army from Finland and Ukraine to conclude a separate peace with the Central Council, to give Turkey some parts of Transcaucasia, provide duty-free export of raw materials, Germany. Ultimatum was later supplemented by the requirements of the demobilization of the Russian army and Navy, the payment of indemnities in 6 billion. brands. Total land of futurism have been rejected from Russia with a total area of 780 thousand. kV. km with a population of 56 million. people (one third of the population of the former Russian Empire, including 40% of industrial workers). There was almost a third of the country's rail network, vyplavlâlos′ more than 70% of iron and steel, produced 89% coal. A German ultimatum was accepted, and March 3, 1918 g. So, unprecedented in the world history of assignments uâzvlâvših patriotic feelings of millions of Russian citizens, the Bolsheviks had retained power over Russia and got the truth, for a short time, a peaceful respite.

Результаты (английский) 2:

It was a compromise, "in every way to delay the signing of the peace" (Lenin), "in the event of a German ultimatum to declare war ended, but the world did not sign" (Trotsky). "We come out of the war, but they have to refuse to sign a peace treaty." German troops launched an offensive in the direction of Petrograd, Moscow and Kiev, sweeping away everything in its path loosely organized Red Army troops. Lenin's resolution on the conclusion of peace was accepted. The Soviet government received the new German ultimatum. Apart from the loss of the occupied territories, Russia had to abandon Estonia and Latvia, withdraw the army from Finland and Ukraine, conclude with the Central Rada separate peace, to give Turkey some areas of the Caucasus, to give Germany the right to duty-free export of raw materials. Later, an ultimatum was supplemented by the requirements of the demobilization of the Russian army and navy, the payment of indemnities to 6 billion. Marks. Total of Russia were rejected land with total area of ​​780 thousand sq. M. km with a population of 56 million. people (one-third of the population of the former Russian Empire, including 40% of industrial workers). There was almost a third of the country's rail network, over 70% of smelted iron and steel, mining 89% of coal. German ultimatum was accepted, and March 3, 1918 z. So, the price unprecedented in world history concessions bite patriotic feelings of millions of Russian citizens, the Bolsheviks retained power over Russia, and received, although for a short time, a peaceful respite.

Результаты (английский) 3:

a compromise was reached: "to delay the signing of peace" (lenin), "in the event of a german ultimatum to declare war прекращенной, but the world is not подписывать» (trotsky). "we come out of the war, but were forced to abandon the signing of a peace treaty. german troops have moved in the direction of petrograd, moscow and kiev, sweeping in its path красноармейские loosely structured groups. the resolution was adopted lenin on the conclusion of peace. the soviet government has been a german ultimatum. in addition to the loss of the occupied territories, russia had to abandon the estonia and latvia, to withdraw the army from finland and ukraine, to conclude a separate peace with the central rada, to turkey, some parts of the caucasus, to germany right duty-free export of raw materials. later, an ultimatum was supplemented by the demobilization of the army and navy, the payment of contributions in the 6 billion. marks. all of russia отторгались land total area of 780 thousand. kv. km, with a population of 56 million. people (one third of the population of the former russian empire, including 40% of industrial workers). there was almost a third of the railway network of the country выплавлялось more than 70% of iron and steel, добывалось 89% of coal. the german ultimatum was adopted, and on 3 march 1918.г. so the price is unprecedented in the history of the world concessions, уязвлявших patriotic feelings million russian citizens, the bolsheviks had power over russia and got a really short time, just a break.